Skip to main content

Putting Power Back Into Separation of Powers Analysis: Why the SEC-PCAOB Structure is Constitutional

Posted by on Monday, November 2, 2009 in En Banc, Free Enterprise Fund v. PCAOB, Roundtables, Volume 62, Number 5.

PDF Download Link

This article has two aims: to explain the historical context and reasons that led Congress to design the administrative structure at issue in Free Enterprise Fund, and to provide a realistic account of how that structure actually functions in practice. The article is, thus, a kind of “Brandeis brief” for this important case concerning the constitutional structure for the administrative state.  The article seeks to provide a rich understanding of the unique, long-established structures of financial regulation and an appreciation for how the administrative structures at issue actually work.  With a clear understanding of these elements in mind, the article argues that the Court should find the Sarbanes-Oxley Act constitutional.